The article provides a comprehensive overview of the Biden administration's efforts to address SAVE student debt relief and the challenges faced in implementing these student loan initiatives.
The Biden administration has made student loan debt relief a key focus of its education policy, attempting to ease the financial burden for millions of borrowers through various initiatives. These efforts began with an ambitious plan for large-scale debt cancellation, which the Supreme Court ultimately struck down in June 2023. In response, the administration pivoted to other approaches, including introducing the SAVE (Saving on a Valuable Education) plan, which aims to provide more favorable repayment terms for borrowers.
However, these efforts have faced significant legal opposition, with multiple lawsuits filed by Republican-led states and interest groups seeking to block the administration's latest rulemaking efforts. The SAVE plan, in particular, has been partially implemented but faces ongoing legal challenges, leaving many borrowers uncertain of their obligation.
Additionally, the administration has pursued targeted loan relief through negotiated rulemaking sessions, but these proposals have also been met with preemptive legal action.
Table of Contents
SAVE Student Debt Relief Legal Status
- Biden's initial debt cancellation plan proposed forgiving up to $20,000 for eligible borrowers.
- The Supreme Court ruled against this plan in June 2023, citing a lack of authority under the HEROES Act.
- The administration introduced the SAVE plan as an alternative, replacing the REPAYE plan.
- SAVE plan features include higher income protection, lower assessment of discretionary income, and early loan forgiveness for low-balance borrowers.
- Legal challenges have partially blocked the implementation of the SAVE plan.
- Targeted loan relief proposals through negotiated rulemaking are also facing legal opposition.
Expected Next Steps
The future of student debt relief remains uncertain as legal battles continue to unfold. The administration will likely pursue multiple avenues to provide relief, including defending the SAVE plan in court and potentially seeking new legislative solutions.
Financial aid administrators and borrowers alike are grappling with the constantly changing landscape, making it crucial for the Department of Education to maintain clear communication and up-to-date information. As court cases progress, including the upcoming Eighth Circuit Court hearing on October 24, 2024, stakeholders will be closely watching for any developments that could impact the future of student loan relief programs.
The administration may also need to explore alternative strategies or seek bipartisan support for more comprehensive student loan reform to overcome the ongoing legal challenges.
SAVE Student Debt Relief Legal History and Timeline
Below is a table for easy lookups of the legal challenges, the results, and the upcoming schedule.
| Date | Category | Event | Lawsuit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 20, 2021 | Payment Pause | Biden takes office, extends student loan payment pause. | Student Loan Debt Cancellation Lawsuit |
| Aug 6, 2021 | Payment Pause | Payment pause extended through Jan 31, 2022. | Student Loan Debt Cancellation Lawsuit |
| Apr 6, 2022 | Payment Pause | Payment pause extended through Aug 31, 2022. | Student Loan Debt Cancellation Lawsuit |
| Aug 24, 2022 | Debt Cancellation | Biden announces debt cancellation plan (up to $10,000/$20,000). | Student Loan Debt Cancellation Lawsuit |
| Nov 22, 2022 | Payment Pause | Payment pause extended through Jun 30, 2023 due to legal challenges. | Student Loan Debt Cancellation Lawsuit |
| Feb 28, 2023 | Legal Challenge | Supreme Court agrees to hear debt cancellation case. | Student Loan Debt Cancellation Lawsuit |
| Jun 30, 2023 | Legal Challenge | Supreme Court blocks Biden's debt cancellation plan. | Student Loan Debt Cancellation Lawsuit |
| Jun 30, 2023 | New Initiative | ED announces plans for negotiated rulemaking on targeted relief. | Neg Reg Student Loan Relief Rules Lawsuit |
| Jul 10, 2023 | SAVE Plan | ED releases final rule on SAVE repayment plan. | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| Jul 31, 2023 | SAVE Plan | ED opens beta application for SAVE plan sign-up. | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| Aug 22, 2023 | SAVE Plan | Portions of SAVE plan early implemented. | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| October, 2023 | SAVE Plan | Borrowers previously enrolled in REPAYE have SAVE Plan terms automatically applied to their loans. | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| October 13, 2023 | New Initiative | ED holds first of 3 negotiated rulemaking sessions to forge a path toward targeted student loan cancellation. | Neg Reg Student Loan Relief Rules Lawsuit |
| December 13, 2023 | New Initiative | ED held final negotiated rulemaking sessions for student loan cancellation on which many topics don’t reach consensus. • There wasn’t enough time to discuss the topic of financial hardship, and was rescheduled for early 2024. | Neg Reg Student Loan Relief Rules Lawsuit |
| Jan 21, 2024 | SAVE Plan | Early cancellation for low-balance borrowers takes effect. | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| Feb 21, 2024 | Debt Cancellation | ED cancels $1.2 billion in student debt under SAVE plan. | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| Feb 23, 2023 | New Initiative | Student loan relief negotiating committee reconvenes for financial hardship discussion. | Neg Reg Student Loan Relief Rules Lawsuit |
| Feb 26, 2023 | New Initiative | Student loan relief negotiated rulemaking committee reaches consensus on financial hardship language. | Neg Reg Student Loan Relief Rules Lawsuit |
| Mar 28, 2024 | Legal Challenge | Kansas and Missouri file lawsuits against SAVE plan. | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| April 17, 2024 | New Initiative | ED releases draft rules related to debt relief from the initial negotiated rulemaking session held in late 2023. • Does not include the financial hardship topic, which was negotiated later than the other topics. | Neg Reg Student Loan Relief Rules Lawsuit |
| Jun 24, 2024 | Legal Challenge | Courts issue temporary injunctions against parts of SAVE plan. | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| Jun 28, 2024 | SAVE Plan | Department of Education removes online application to apply for Income Driven Repayment Plans (including SAVE) from studentaid.gov website. • Paper applications remain available but are not being processed by servicers. Borrowers enrolled in the SAVE plan are placed into interest-free administrative forbearance by servicers. | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| Jun 30, 2024 | Legal Challenge | The 10th Circuit Court of Appeals halted the Kansas injunction, meaning the recalculation of monthly payments could move forward. • The Missouri judgment remained in place. | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| July 1, 2024 | SAVE Plan | ICR (except to repay consolidation loans that include Parent PLUS loans) and PAYE new enrollments sunsetted per the final SAVE rules. • This part of the SAVE rule was not blocked by any courts. | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| Jul 18, 2024 | Legal Challenge | Federal appeals court blocks entire SAVE Plan | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| Aug 9, 2024 | Legal Challenge | The 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruling extends the brief pause ordered in July, blocking the administration from “any further forgiveness of principal or interest, from not charging borrowers accrued interest, and from further implementing SAVE’s payment-threshold provisions.” • This presumably permits the sunsetting of the ICR and PAYE plans since those provisions are not explicitly noted in the decision, causing ED to stop accepting new applications for those plans on August 9. | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| Aug 28, 2024 | Legal Challenge | Supreme Court denies request to vacate SAVE Plan injunction. | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| Sep 3, 2024 | Legal Challenge | DOJ asks Eighth Circuit to consider and decide the SAVE student loan plan appeal on an expedited basis. • This would allow SCOTUS to hear any further appeal in this upcoming term if necessary, which would mean a final decision by June 2025. | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| Sep 3, 2024 | Legal Challenge | Seven states file lawsuit to block new debt relief plan. | Neg Reg Student Loan Relief Rules Lawsuit |
| Sep 4, 2024 | Legal Challenge | Eighth Circuit sets oral arguments for SAVE plan appeal (Oct 24, 2024). | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| Sep 6, 2024 | Legal Challenge | District Court rules the administration is temporarily restrained from implementing proposed student loan relief rules. • Preemptively including financial hardship, despite the fact that a proposed rule has not yet been issued. | Neg Reg Student Loan Relief Rules Lawsuit |
| Sep 18, 2024 | Legal Challenge | Judge extends temporary restraining order for an additional 14 days. | Neg Reg Student Loan Relief Rules Lawsuit |
| Oct 3, 2024 | Legal Challenge | Georgia judge determined that the state of Georgia lacked standing in the legal challenge to the program and allowed the temporary restraining order to lapse. | Neg Reg Student Loan Relief Rules Lawsuit |
| Oct 3, 2024 | Legal Challenge | A judge in Missouri issued a preliminary injunction against the administration's program shortly after the decision from Georgia. | Neg Reg Student Loan Relief Rules Lawsuit |
| Nov 15, 2024 | SAVE Plan | ED publishes an Interim Final Rule to reopen the applications for and allow borrowers to enroll in the Income-Contingent Repayment (ICR) and Pay As You Earn (PAYE) repayment plans, effective December 15, 2024, through July 1, 2027. • This change addresses the current lack of an available ICR option after the rollout of the new SAVE plan (which replaced REPAYE, PAYE, and ICR). | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| Dec 20, 2024 | Legal Challenge | The Department of Education withdraws notice of proposed rulemaking for the student loan debt relief for hardship proposed rule issued October 30, 2024. | Neg Reg Student Loan Relief Rules Lawsuit |
| Dec 26, 2024 | Legal Challenge | The Department of Education withdraws notice of proposed rulemaking for the student loan debt relief proposed rules issued April 17, 2024. | Neg Reg Student Loan Relief Rules Lawsuit |
| Feb 18, 2024 | Legal Challenge | The 8th Circuit Court of Appeals issued its ruling, upholding the injunction, continuing to block the SAVE plan in its entirety, including the forgiveness provisions, which subsequently blocked the administration from processing forgiveness for borrowers enrolled in PAYE and ICR plans as well. • The case will now return to the Eastern Missouri lower district court, which is tasked with issuing a final ruling on the fate of the SAVE plan. | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| Feb 21, 2024 | SAVE Plan | The Department of Education removed access to all IDR repayment plans from the studentaid.gov website. | SAVE Plan Lawsuit |
| Date | Category | Event | Lawsuit |
Conclusion
As you can see, the student loan forgiveness journey has been tumultuous at best. The current standing is that SAVE and IDR access to repayment plans has been removed.
For additional information on the impact on borrowers, an application for loan consolidation, and a Student Borrow FAQ, check out SAVE Plan Court Actions: Impact on Borrowers at Federal Student Aid.
If you haven't seen our previous writeup on the student debt relief executive order, check out our article About the Student Loan Debt Relief Order in 2022. You'll also see tips on avoiding student loan scams and actual Department of Education emails to compare official announcements.